top of page
Search

The rise in incivility

Desleigh White
2 days ago
4 min read


Many of my conversations at present land in the same place. Incivility.


We’re not rude to each other in the conversation, the topic is incivility. It’s behaviour that is increasing in my experience.


Harvard Business Review did an article on it in 2013, well before the rise of AI. The Price of Incivility. And I am seeing it increasing exponentially with the increased use in AI. I see a link.


People say appalling things hiding behind technology, including SMS, email, social media etc. The proverbial keyboard warriors. And some also do it in person. I am seeing an increase in online and virtual incivility and rudeness and an increase in the in person abruptness and disrespectful communication.


Incivility has a cost. The article, which is now 13 years old, so I am guessing things will have changed, identifies that “among workers who’ve been on the receiving end of incivility:

  • 48% intentionally decreased their work effort.

  • 47% intentionally decreased the time spent at work.

  • 38% intentionally decreased the quality of their work.

  • 80% lost work time worrying about the incident.

  • 63% lost work time avoiding the offender.

  • 66% said that their performance declined.

  • 78% said that their commitment to the organization declined.

  • 12% said that they left their job because of the uncivil treatment.

  • 25% admitted to taking their frustration out on customers”.


I recall the times that I have been subjected to incivility, I decreased my discretionary effort, I worked the hours I was paid for and no longer (think a 25% daily reduction, I had regularly worked 10 hour days, and started working 7.6 hours).


The other things that are impacted:

The way people talk about the workplace. Including when they leave reviews on sites like Glassdoor and Seek. I had the misfortune of meeting one CEO (a psychologist – I appreciate irony), who was so rude, the Glassdoor reviews literally named their role along with the behaviours. As I said to my CEO at the time, when people show you who they are, believe them the first time.


There is less creativity.


Culture takes a hit, which means performance and results suffer.


With AI rampant, I am guessing that incivility will lead to less critical thinking and accepting the AI results, irrespective of their accuracy, completeness etc.


On the AI topic I wonder if we’re all expecting people to be as quick in responding and as sycophantic when they do?


You lose customers. I am reminded of a café near home. I went one day and the father / son owners were arguing and being rude to one another. I never went back. And I tell people why I don’t go there.  


People will not help you. It literally is that simple, when you need something from the person you have been rude to, they will likely choose not to help you, or if they have to because its a workplace, it will not be as much as otherwise might have been the case.

Case in point - another person with a psychology degree (!?!) has been bullying me via SMS for months and now wants something from me. I choose not to respond.


But wait, there’s hope. There is so much we can do.


We can train ourselves in things like perspective taking. I ask people about what others might think when I am coaching. The insights are always fascinating. Find a coach who will challenge you to think differently.


We can develop our own emotional intelligence. Start with the ‘self’ pillars. Self-Awareness is the  ability to recognise and understand our own emotions and behaviours. It involves being aware of our internal state and how it affects our behaviour and interactions with others.


And then self-management, which is the capacity to control our emotions and manage our reactions and impulses. This includes emotional self-control, transparency, adaptability, initiative, and optimism.


The other pillars of emotional intelligence are just as important.


Social Awareness, the ability to understand and appreciate the feelings and perspectives of others. It involves recognising and responding to the emotions of others and being aware of our own emotions. It’s obviously very aligned with me first point above.


And finally, relationship management, being the skill to manage relationships effectively, including understanding and managing our own emotions and those of others. This includes being aware of our own emotions and those of others and being able to influence them positively.


Some ways to develop it:


Start young. I was on a call for Dr Marc Brackett’s book club recently and these were the results of a survey he did with the audience. They shared that the results were representative outside the audience too. The recording is on his YouTube channel. It’s well worth a watch.



 

There are books, Marc’s included. I bought an age-appropriate book for a young person I mentor. I was delighted that he already had it, from his case worker.


There is the app that Marc’s organisation developed, HowWeFeel. It helps with that first pillar, because it helps us identify how we are feeling and name it. Naming it is the first step.


 

There is the card game that I use in my work (coaching, human resources, workshops etc), Emotional Culture Deck. There is a free pdf online: riders&elephants Store.

I use this for myself as well, to help identify how I am feeling and how I would prefer to feel. 


Emotional intelligence is crucial, especially now. It helps with effective communication, teamwork, and culture, and these help improve performance and results, including financial results. It helps us navigate social complexities, make informed decisions, and manage pressure and stress better.


We need to change how we treat one another and develop our collective emotional intelligence.


Or we can continue doing nothing, in which case we won’t need AI to do anything dastardly; we’ll have created a dysfunctional, dehumanised, disconnected,  desensitised, dystopian world where incivility is the norm.

 

The link to the HBR article for those interested, it is behind a paywall. The Price of Incivility

 

 


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page